18 Best Car Insurance Companies 2023: Pros & Cons

10 minutes read

The top auto insurance companies offer their clients more than just the affordable coverage they need. A hassle-free approach to managing policies and making payments is one of the additional services they offer that put customers’ needs first. Some of the top auto insurance providers in the world are shown below.

1. Allstate Car Insurance

Based on market share, Allstate is the fourth-largest auto insurance, and it offers a wide range of beneficial coverage options that set it apart from the competition for many motorists, particularly those who drive unusual cars. Drivers can earn points toward hotels, gift cards, and other wonderful incentives through the rewards program offered by Allstate, which offers additional benefits.

One of the few insurance companies that protect specialized equipment is Allstate. Even while Allstate’s full coverage policies are more expensive on average than those offered by other companies, drivers who have spent money upgrading their cars with the greatest audio systems probably need the more comprehensive coverage that Allstate offers. Collectors of classic and antique cars can purchase Allstate’s vintage car insurance, which will consider the vehicle’s higher intrinsic worth in the event of expensive damage.

Pros

It has coverage for vintage or unique cars
It has a specialized points-based incentive scheme
There are numerous opportunities to save money.
Policies can be purchased and serviced online or through a local agent
There are several ways to track and file claims

Cons

The rates are higher than usual.
Regional variations exist in J.D. Power’s customer satisfaction ratings.
J.D. Power claims the satisfaction score is subpar.
The scores for digital shopping and service from J.D. Power are below average.
The NAIC complaint index overall is higher than usual.

2. State Farm Insurance

According to market share, State Farm is the largest national auto insurer, and because of its reputation and reach, most drivers in most states consider it to be one of the finest providers of auto insurance. With a wide range of personal and business insurance products, it puts the needs of the customer first, as seen by the sizeable local agent network.

If you value expert advice while discussing your policy, State Farm has more than 19,000 licensed insurance specialists who are accessible in localities all across the United States. With the help of a well-regarded mobile app, you can file car claims and get in touch with your agent while on the road.

Pros

Large network of privileged local representatives
Teen drivers could save money with the Steer Clear program
A telematics package called Drive Safe & Save is available
An above-average J.D. Power claims satisfaction rating

Cons

High-risk drivers could not be allowed to use it
Good compliance index rating from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC)
Not offered in all 50 states at the moment
The rate of complete coverage for drivers with bad credit is higher than average
Considering that auto policies typically have six-month durations, premiums may rise twice each year.

3. Geico Car Insurance

One of the reasons we identified Geico Car Insurance as a top business it’s because of its long history as a well-known, dependable vehicle insurer, which is reflected in its high Bankrate Score. Almost all types of drivers can be covered, making it possible for people with a history of reckless driving to purchase their auto insurance.

Pros

Typically available to high-risk drivers.
They have highly-rated digital apps and mobile tools.
It has an array of discounts.
It offers a telematics program called DriveEasy.

Cons

Customer service scores vary by region
Fewer coverage options than most competitors

4. Woolworths Car Insurance

Woolworths Car Insurance is for people who want to protect their vehicles from unintentional loss or damage brought on by an accident, a natural disaster, theft, or malicious damage by others, as well as liability for loss or damage to other people’s property if the driver is at fault.

As long as it is two years or less from the date of registration, Woolworths Insurance promises that they will give a new replacement for qualified policyholders if their automobile is written off. Additionally, they cover you against theft and vandalism and will pay the cost for damage to another person’s automobile or property up to $20 million.

5. Allianz Car Insurance

Having to acquire automobile rental insurance under duress is one of the less appealing parts of renting a car. Instead of opting for the insurance provided by the rental car agency, Allianz Car Insurance is a wise choice.

Under the name Allianz Car Damage Protector, Allianz offers a travel insurance plan. The majority of the planet is covered at $9 per day.

In its simplest form, Collision Damage Waiver Insurance is what Allianz Car Insurance is. It’s intended to pay for the costs related to your rental automobile being stolen or damaged.

Keep in mind that the amount of coverage is only $40,000, so renting a more exotic vehicle is not going to be very beneficial.

Pros

Excellent Insurance Partner
Affordable cost

Cons

Counterfeit Credit Card Cover
$40k is the maximum limit

6. Progressive Car Insurance

For many drivers, it may be worthwhile to purchase a Progressive Car Insurance policy. Auto insurance policies and add-on coverage choices are available from the insurer in various sizes.

Progressive Car Insurance is full coverage premiums for safe drivers are typically 7% less expensive than the national average. Furthermore, the company offers adaptable coverage options that appeal to a variety of drivers, including usage-based insurance and rideshare insurance.

Pros

Numerous choices for coverage
There are discounts for usage-based insurance
acclaimed mobile application

Cons

Ratings of average customer service
Snapshot initiative may result in premium increases for some drivers

7. Direct Line Car Insurance

Operating as an investment holding company with a stake in the provision of general insurance services, Direct Line The business is divided into five segments: Run-off, Motor, Home, Rescue & Other Personal Lines, and Commercial.

Personal auto insurance coverage and the related legal expenditures industry make up the motor segment. Incorporated on July 26, 1988, Direct Line Insurance Group has its main office in Bromley, England.

8. GAP Car Insurance

Guaranteed auto protection is known as a “GAP” in the insurance market. Gap insurance is an extra auto coverage that pays for any discrepancy between the insured value of a car and the remaining loan or lease that the owner is required to pay. Gap insurance is required to cover any shortfall between your auto insurance payout and the balance owed on the car if it is totaled or stolen before the loan is paid off.

Your lender may mandate gap insurance for specific models of automobiles, trucks, or SUVs if you’re financing your vehicle purchase. For example, luxury sedans, SUVs, or other specific types of SUVs may depreciate and lose value at higher rates than average.

9. Root Car Insurance

If finding a low-cost quote is your main goal, and you’re a responsible driver, Root is a smart choice for auto insurance. Root, a usage-based startup, uses a mobile app to track your driving over a test-drive period and adjusts your auto insurance rates by how you perform. However, Root’s whole business strategy is centered on this telemetry tracking technology, unlike other significant auto insurance providers that provide usage-based programs as an add-on discount.

Because of this individualized method, it is impossible to determine the cost of Root auto insurance coverage without taking a test drive and seeing an average rate. Customers can save up to $900 each year, the corporation claims in its advertising.

Pros

Rate reductions when driving skills increase
An excellent mobile experience
Adolescent drivers and anyone with a history of accidents are examples of higher-risk drivers

Cons

Only drivers who prioritize efficient and trustworthy customer service
Anyone who requires specific insurance, such as a gap or ridesharing insurance

10. Direct Auto Car Insurance

Having been in operation for 99 years, Direct Auto Car Insurance is a more modest insurer. While only 11 states can access the company’s various plans, it does provide a variety of them. High-risk drivers are advised to use it because of its higher financial strength rating, wide range of discounts, and these features.

Pros

Excellent for risky drivers
Offers a variety of offers
Quotes and claim processes that are simple and clear

Cons

Customer requirements are not being met quickly enough
Most industry studies lack these pieces of information
a small number of options (11 states)

11. The General Car Insurance

Nashville-based For drivers who are deemed high-risk, such as those who have a history of moving violations, have less-than-perfect credit or have let their insurance expire, The General specializes in nonstandard vehicle insurance. A company called The General offers quotations from three similar insurance providers.

Insurance companies typically group drivers into levels. These categories include “standard,” or typical, clean-record drivers, and “nonstandard,” or high-risk drivers. Drivers in the nonstandard group often have to pay more for insurance. That’s because nonstandard drivers are charged more since they are more expensive to insure. After all, insurance companies believe they are more likely to file claims.

Pros

Provides SR-22 filing services for drivers who must demonstrate their insurance coverage to a state
It focuses on high-risk motorists who could have trouble acquiring affordable insurance
It enables you to manage your account, submit claims, and make payments online and via a mobile app

Cons

A high number of automobile insurance-related complaints were made to state insurance departments
You must search elsewhere if you want good driver coverage alternatives like accident forgiveness or disappearing deductibles
It does not provide usage-based insurance, which might be more affordable for prudent drivers depending on their driving patterns
It does not provide new vehicle replacement

12. Tesco Car Insurance

Tesco Car Insurance has a good selection of features and is highly recommended.

There are a few methods to lower the cost of your coverage if you are a regular Tesco customer and enjoy the concept of having Tesco Car Insurance. For instance, while it’s wise to compare costs on comparison shopping sites, it’s important to know that Clubcard Members who request quotes directly from Tesco will always receive a discount as long as they provide Tesco with their Clubcard number.

Pros

Reduction of cancellation costs
It’s open seven days a week for customer service

Cons

Only if you purchase the add-on are keys covered

13. LV Car Insurance

LV Car Insurance has some of the highest customer satisfaction scores in the sector and a strong collection of features, but premiums seem to be mid-market, so if you’re looking for the lowest quotation, you might want to look elsewhere. In any case, LV is a good choice to take into account.

A lot of interesting benefits are included in policies purchased directly from LV. For instance, comprehensive plans include coverage for misfuelling, lost or stolen keys, and windscreen replacement and repair, as well as personal accident coverage of £10,000.

Pros

Excellent Trustpilot user reviews
A solid selection of features is offered

Cons

Those seeking the least expensive insurance
Extra for a courtesy car

14. AAA Auto Insurance

Auto insurance from AAA is often only offered to members, but the benefits and savings might be enough to convince you to sign up.

Regional insurance firms with distinct names and emblems but similar business models provide AAA auto insurance. You would probably need to join your local club to obtain insurance because AAA club membership functions similarly to that. Although there is a cost associated with it, the subsequent reduction in your auto insurance premium might make it worthwhile.

15. RAC Car Insurance

Their website lists the following features as standard inclusions: windscreen repair or replacement, valuables coverage, a courtesy car, new locks, 60 days of EU cover, etc.

Those seeking additional coverage can select their “Plus” policy. This insurance is highly rated for features but also offers child seat protection, uninsured driver protection (to safeguard your NCD if you are not at fault), and transportation home following an accident in the UK if your car is not roadworthy.

Pros

The Plus plan has more features
Family name

Cons

Some features are absent from the fundamental comprehensive plan
No operating other vehicles

16. AA Car Insurance

For its customers, AA insurance has a lot to offer. Our priority is keeping you secure. AA auto insurance rates are dependable. A 24-hour claim line is manned by AA insurance every day of the year to ensure your protection. A knowledgeable AA representative is available to you at all times by phone.

When you add online breakdown coverage to your auto insurance, you may save 25% and take advantage of AA’s speedy and effective breakdown and recovery service. If you’ve been in an accident, AA insurance will aid with overnight accommodations or transportation to support you in difficult circumstances. If you have to wait for auto maintenance, AA even offers a courtesy vehicle.

17. Esure Car Insurance

Esure Car Insurance offers a solid set of important features. However, there are a few elements that are absent that you should be aware of. For instance, basic key insurance only covers theft (loss or accidental protection is available for an additional charge). And it’s only when it can be proven that the person in possession of the keys, transmitter, or entry card is aware of the identity or location of your automobile.

Pros

Esure car insurance has the availability of customer service every day of the week
Favorable customer reviews

Cons

Increasing cancellation costs
Key loss or damage is an additional cost

18. USAA Auto Insurance

The excellent customer reviews and inexpensive coverage choices, such as accident forgiveness, of USAA Auto Insurance are well known. But not everyone is eligible, and the coverage is subject to tight qualifying guidelines.

Only military personnel, veterans, and their families are eligible to purchase USAA motor insurance, severely limiting the pool of potential customers. One of the better choices is USAA insurance coverage if you qualify.

Pros

Reasonable prices
Outstanding results on J.D. Power customer surveys
Outstanding mobile application
Financial rating of A++

Cons

Not offered to everyone
Only 25 states now provide SafePilot.
Not the most affordable choice after a DUI

Final Thoughts

Finding the best auto insurance provider in your region takes more than just looking at affordable quotes. When picking the best company, you need to consider other aspects besides the average cost of auto insurance. You can find the best auto insurance in your state with the help of our checklist.

You May Want to Check These Posts: